Benutzer:GerhardSchuhmacher/Disk
nowiki>
Diskussion 6. Dezember
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]Vorlage:REMOVE THIS TEMPLATE WHEN CLOSING THIS AfD
Small company with no notability, almost completely written with sources from the company itself and in advertising style. Google almost doesn't know the company with exactly 15 (!) hits for the original German name [1] and 19 für the English [2], some of which come from Wikipedia and WikiCommons. Some of the (few) independent sources used to write the article don't even mention the company (e.g. [3] and therefore the article basically just presents the views of the company itself, while the role of one rare independent example (a short study for the German Bundestag) is not only presented twice, but also grossly exaggerated. (It only uses the company to explain some rather trivial information which could also have been found in the Wikipedia). Please also note that there is the possibility for paid contend, as the company declared: "Companies are included in the world's largest encyclopedia if they either generate more than 100 million euros in annual sales or if they simply deserve to be mentioned. We are therefore very pleased to be included in this group. In the following months, the entry in Wikipedia, which is currently only available in German, will also be translated into other languages. Furthermore, additional categories and links to the individual rare earths, base metals and secondary metals are created." [4] That's exactly what happened in the German Wikipedia, where about 25 paragraphs with clearly advertising content have been added in ever rare earth article and some others, where there was even less connection to that company. Therefore there has been a unanimously consensus (everyone except the author) to delete that entry, which has been done today, see [5]. Andol (talk) 19:41, 6 December 2022 (UTC)
- Note: This discussion has been included in the deletion sorting lists for the following topics: Companies, Germany, and Switzerland. Shellwood (talk) 21:10, 6 December 2022 (UTC)
Kleine Firma ohne Bekanntheit, fast vollständig mit Quellen aus dem Unternehmen selbst und im Werbestil geschrieben. Google kennt das Unternehmen fast nicht mit genau 15 (!) Treffern für den deutschen Originalnamen [1] und 19 für den englischen [2], von denen einige aus Wikipedia und WikiCommons stammen. Einige der (wenigen) unabhängigen Quellen, die für den Artikel verwendet wurden, erwähnen das Unternehmen nicht einmal (z.B. [3] und daher stellt der Artikel im Grunde nur die Ansichten des Unternehmens selbst dar, während die Rolle eines seltenen unabhängigen Beispiels (eine Kurzstudie für den Deutschen Bundestag) nicht nur zweimal dargestellt, sondern auch grob übertrieben wird. (Es verwendet das Unternehmen nur, um einige eher triviale Informationen zu erklären, die auch in der Wikipedia hätten gefunden werden können). Bitte beachten Sie auch, dass es die Möglichkeit zur kostenpflichtigen Auseinandersetzung gibt, wie das Unternehmen erklärte: "Unternehmen werden in die größte Enzyklopädie der Welt aufgenommen, wenn sie entweder mehr als 100 Millionen Euro Jahresumsatz erwirtschaften oder wenn sie es einfach verdienen, erwähnt zu werden. Wir freuen uns daher sehr, in diese Gruppe aufgenommen zu werden. In den kommenden Monaten wird der Eintrag in Wikipedia, der derzeit nur auf Deutsch verfügbar ist, auch in andere Sprachen übersetzt. Darüber hinaus werden zusätzliche Kategorien und Verknüpfungen zu den einzelnen Seltenen Erden, Basismetallen und Sekundärmetallen geschaffen." [4] Genau das passierte in der deutschen Wikipedia, wo etwa 25 Absätze mit eindeutig werblichen Inhalten in immer seltenen Erden Artikel hinzugefügt wurden und einige andere, wo es noch weniger Verbindung zu diesem Unternehmen gab. Daher gab es einen einstimmigen Konsens (alle außer dem Autor), diesen Eintrag zu löschen, was heute geschehen ist, siehe [5]. Andol (Diskussion) 19:41, 6. Dezember 2022 (UTC)
Vorlage:Article for deletion/dated Vorlage:Short description
The Institute for Rare Earths and Metals AG is an informal network in the international raw materials market and a player with the "core business" of metal analysis and the storage of contingents of intended or commercially traded substances. The core business has been carried out since 2020 with the Swiss partner company Cosmotrans AG.
The main interest of the institute's customers is the database, which is available on a subscription basis with daily updated prices: In addition to the eponymous Rare-earth element, 900 metals and alloys, and 4,500 other metal products, are listed there. The company's headquarters are located in Lucerne, Switzerland.
Commodity trading position
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]The unique feature of the Institute for Rare Earths and Metals is its database with the daily updated prices for over 5000 market-relevant materials of Metallurgy, traditionally rare earths and Clean Energy Metals, determined after 10 years of preparation. The data can be viewed by members.
The "core business" described by the Institute itself and also in the Swiss commercial register is the "carrying out of technical, physical and chemical investigations. The company aims to provide services in the field of analysis of raw materials, minerals, metals, rare earths and in the evaluation and storage of such products."[1] Since 2020, transport, storage and insurance for substances prepared for trading (e.g. for analysis) or for substances already on the market have also been arranged for the processing of transactions.
A company activ in this trade describes the importance of the analyses carried out in the institute's laboratories: "The international recognition of the ISE, especially among auditors, universities and banks, gives the Institute's documentation work the desired international acceptance. Therefore, all analyzes and assessments are made exclusively by the ISE.[Note 1] Regarding the cooperation partner Storage of the ISE: "Cosmotrans AG is an independent Swiss joint-stock company that [...] has also been offering the handling of valuable metals for around ten years. Cosmotrans AG is fully accepted by banks and insurance companies."[2]
In the Scientific Services of the German Bundestag of February 2022, the Institute is cited several times in the status report Rare Earths as an Important Resource and described as a "private-sector consulting firm."[3]
Transit trade Switzerland
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]With the free trade zone in the area of Zurich Airport, the deposited goods are legally not on Swiss soil: "The term transit trade covers all the commercial transactions of companies based in Switzerland in which the goods are bought and sold without the goods ever crossing a Swiss border."[4]
History
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]After a project call for proposals in 2008, there was a conference with experts "to solve bottlenecks in the manufacturing processes of large industrial companies in the field of rare earths." To collect and analyze the data, the "Institute for Rare Earths" was founded in 2011 as Association.[5]
Formation (self-portrayal)
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]In a press release in 2012, the Institute stated the following as the motive for founding it:
After the dependence of the world economy on oil, which became imminent in the 1970s, there followed a second dependence at the beginning of the 21st century – the one "on the so-called ‚rare earths‘: These 17 metals, which are difficult to obtain, are becoming needed in numerous high-tech areas [...and] are among the most valuable raw materials in the world today." The largest supplier of the indispensable elements by far is China. The People's Republic has the market in hand. "The reason for this monopoly position is, among other things, that China has so far not paid attention to environmental compatibility when mining. Air, soil and water were ruthlessly polluted."[6]
One reason would also be that China will need its own production in the future: „'If China continues to grow strongly, the People's Republic will change from an exporter to an importer of rare earths in ten years at the latest,' expects Arndt Uhlendorff, chief analyst at the Institute for Rare Earths and Metals.“[7]
From Association to Business Corporation
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]In 2013, the prices of around 600 metals were regularly available to customers. In 2018, daily updated prices from the areas of rare earths, strategic metals, base metals, technology metals and isotopes were published.
Since 2019, the ISE has been cooperating with a Swiss partner company that carries out metal analysis to identify 74 elements. "Verified persons [...] and verified goods that (are) inspected, analyzed and evaluated" are permitted on the trading platform. Together with the partner company, storage facilities were offered from 2020 on “2000 square meters of domestic storage space and 5000 square meters of external storage for high-priced metals”.
2021: The Institute for Rare Earths and Metals trades as Aktiengesellschaft in the Canton of Zug: The reasons for moving to Switzerland were the proximity to the warehouse in the free trade zone Zurich Airport and in cooperation with financial institutions to offer trading programs for commodities. The storage capacity in Zurich is 5500 square meters.[8] In September, the headquarters moved to the old town hall in the city of Lucerne.
The Institute employs eight people in administration and five specialists for handling the offers. In the partner company, 60 people work in the laboratory and 12 in the warehouses.
Due to "strongly increasing demand" for its services, the ISE opened a representative office in Dubai in May 2022,[9]
Informal offer
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]In addition to the information from the database as a basis for evaluation for customers, the institute's offer also includes services that are necessary for business transactions. In addition to commercially interested parties, the offer is also used by universities and research institutions.
Database and trading platform
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]Since 2018, the previously informal database has been operated as „Trading platform for rare earths and high-purity metals“ and metal analyses, assessments and bank audits are carried out on behalf of all metals and elements of these groups.[10]
Information Gathering
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]Since 2008, the institute has been surveying the prices "of regular mine operators, producers, refiners, buyers, sellers, brokers and end customers of the metals recently traded". The “metal prices are calculated from several hundred individual sources in order to determine a representative average price for [..] customers.”
The prices of highly specific metals are determined using a simplified capital value method. Ultimately, the aim is to regulate the relationship between value and price in such a way that market participants can find a consensus on fixed product positions on the basis of "market-oriented pricing".[11]
The Institute advises customers in all stages of the offer, as well as on communication with banks and auditors, on insuring metals and also on special offers."[12]
Metal analysis
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]The unique selling point in the trading process is the certification of the quality of the material. In addition to the specially issued certificates, the Institute does not recognize any other analysis reports.
The metal analyzes relate to pure metals, metal alloys, non-conductive materials and to (almost) all metal forms and are carried out in accordance with the (ISO standard DINEN ISO 9001) tested laboratories. Analytes are tested for elements from lithium, number 3 to uranium, number 92 on the periodic table to determine purity by elimination. The tests are carried out directly on the solid using GD/MS (glow discharge/mass spectrometry; solid state MS) without chemical breakdown. The analyses are carried out for a measurable purity of up to 99.999 percent.
The measurement is based on the "IFRS 13 - Fair value principle": The IFRS 13 defines the (fair value), presents the measurement of the fair value and explains the Disclosure requirements.[13]
Transport and storage
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]Since 2020, the storage of metals with related services such as transport, customs formalities, collection is offered. The cooperating Swiss company has been active in this field since 1976. The storage rooms are located in the Swiss domestic area, as well as in the free warehouse at Zurich Airport and in Embraport.[14]
Business relationships
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]Russian customers: After the invasion of Ukraine, the ISE since February 25, 2022 [..] refused any cooperation with Russian companies. It is noted in the notification that „about 20% [.. of the] turnover is forgone“.[15]
Reception
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]In the status report of the Scientific Services (WD 5): Economy and Transport, Food and Agriculture of the German Bundestag Rare Earths as an Important Resource of 16. February 2022, the institute's website is a frequently cited source: Information was taken on the history, the elements (list) with use, occurrence (distribution of mining and deposits) and the Chinese monopoly Earth.[16]
Internally, it is reported that the database is accessed 4,500 to 5,000 times a day.
The Institute presents itself on facebook and twitter and publishes a bimonthly Newsletter.[17]
Note
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]- ↑ The ISE does not accept any analyses prepared by other parties as a basis for its assessment. Reviews are valid for six months. (Acceptance and Validity of Rating. ).access-date=5 September 2022.
References
[Bearbeiten | Quelltext bearbeiten]{reflist}}
[Category:Rare earth companies]] [Category:Companies based in Lucerne]] [Category:2011 establishments]]
</nowiki>
- ↑ Webseite moneyhouse.ch – Institut für Seltene Erden und Metalle (Handelsregisteramt ZG, Handelsregister-Nummer: CH-170.3.041.803-1) access-date=1 September 2022}}
- ↑ Ocean Metal and Minderal Trading AG. In: ommt.ch. Abgerufen am 13. Oktober 2022 (englisch).
- ↑ Report of the Bundestag WD 5 - 3000 - 003/2022 on the resource rare earths: Wissenschaftlicher Dienst des Bundestags 03-2022 Retrieved September 01, 2022.
- ↑ Gerald Hosp, Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ): Rohstoffhandel Schweiz, 4. April 2022. access-date=1 September 2022.
- ↑ History ISE. .access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ Neue Webseite für das Institut für Seltene Erden und Metalle e.V. In: www.pressebox.de. 2. April 2012, abgerufen am 13. Oktober 2022 (deutsch).
- ↑ Wirtschaftswoche: Schutz vor der Rohstoffkrise, 23. August 2012. access-date=1 September 2022.
- ↑ History ISE. .access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ ISE: Representative Office in Dubai (Newsletter May 10, 2022). .access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ Consulting. .access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ ISE: Comments on the principles and methodology of price determination. .access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ ISE Metal Consulting. .access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ IFRS_13. .access-date=1 September 2022.
- ↑ ISE Sicherheitslager. .access-date=1 September 2022.
- ↑ ISE sanctions notification 25 February 2022. . access-date=1 September 2022.
- ↑ Bericht des Deutschen Bundestags zur Ressource Seltene Erden: Scientific Service of the Bundestag 03-2022. access-date=5 September 2022.
- ↑ ISE Newsletter. .access-date=5 September 2022.